Homemade Caramel Coffee Creamer

This post may contain affiliate links. To learn more, please see my disclosure policy.

Homemade coffee creamer has intrigued me for a while now. I can easily go through two bottles of the stuff in a week (don’t judge me). At $3 a pop, that’s $24 per month on coffee creamer. No bueno. So, it’s no wonder I took a stab at making my own coffee creamer. 

 
Homemade Coffee Creamer. Shows you adjustments to make just vanilla coffee creamer and caramel creamer as well.
I used the steps in this tutorial from Lynne @ 365 Days of Baking and More. I made a few tweaks because the tutorial was for vanilla coffee creamer, and I wanted caramel creamer. It was also initially too sweet for my taste, so I added a bit more milk. Adding more milk also makes it stretch a little further. Hey, I’m all about Frugality. 
 
Alright, let’s get on with this. Here’s what you need. 
  • 14-oz can of sweetened condensed milk
  • 18-oz of milk (you can also use 1/2 and 1/2 if you want a thicker consistency)
  • 1-tbsp vanilla extract (the cheap stuff will do, I can’t taste a difference)
  • 2-tbsp of Torani Caramel syrup
Homemade Coffee Creamer. Shows you adjustments to make just vanilla coffee creamer and caramel creamer as well.
Step 1: Pour milk into your container. You can reuse an old coffee creamer bottle if you have one on hand. Also, If you’re only making vanilla coffee creamer, I recommend only initially pouring 14-oz and saving the rest until the end to see if you actually need it. I found that just using 14-oz was too sweet for me, but your taste buds may find that it’s just right.
Homemade Coffee Creamer. Shows you adjustments to make just vanilla coffee creamer and caramel creamer as well.
Step 2: Pour in the can of sweetened condensed milk. It’ll rest at the bottom until you shake it up. Don’t worry – it’s normal.
Homemade Coffee Creamer. Shows you adjustments to make just vanilla coffee creamer and caramel creamer as well.
Step 3: Add the vanilla extract and caramel syrup. Omit the caramel if you just want vanilla coffee creamer.
Homemade Coffee Creamer. Shows you adjustments to make just vanilla coffee creamer and caramel creamer as well.
Step 4: Shake it up! Twist on the lid and shake it like a Polaroid picture. Or a shake weight. Or a maraca. Whatever. Just get everything well incorporated. This is what it looks like after the shaking.
Step 5: Taste test. Take an itty bitty sip and see if it tastes okay. You may need to add more milk if it’s too sweet or more caramel if you want more oomph. Just remember that it wont be as strong in your coffee. So don’t go crazy with adding tons of milk.
And now… some vanity shots of the creamer in my coffee. Because… why not?
Homemade Coffee Creamer. Shows you adjustments to make just vanilla coffee creamer and caramel creamer as well.
Mmm. Dat homemade coffee creamer, yo.
Homemade Coffee Creamer. Shows you adjustments to make just vanilla coffee creamer and caramel creamer as well.
Okay, this is the last picture. I won’t taunt you anymore with all of this deliciousness.
 

Comments

  1. 1

    says

    Hi Jazmin,

    This is great! I didn’t even know you could make your own coffee creamer. I can’t wait to try this!

    Cheers,
    Becky

  2. 10

    says

    Yum! I’ve been making sweet creamer with evaporated milk & sweetened condensed milk and never thought about adding caramel to it. What a good idea! I’m a new follower by way of the Pin Junkie’s Friday link up. Have a great weekend!
    Melanie
    violetsbuds.blogspot.com

  3. 13

    says

    this sounds iike something even i could whip up! any thoughts on how long this would last? i’m not a big coffee drinker so wouldn’t need this much. thinking maybe freezing the extra in ice cube trays for iced coffee would be a good way to go?

    • 14

      says

      I can go through it in a few day, so I never have any leftover! LOL. I think a good guideline would be to use it by the expiration date of the whole milk, as it’s the only perishable thing in the recipe.

      I’ll try freezing a few cube for iced coffee and let you know how it goes. That’s a great idea, Jenn! :)

  4. 19

    says

    Thank you for sharing this. My American friend has been puzzling everyone by asking for coffee creamer since she got to the UK – it’s just something we don’t do. I might make her some or just give her the recipe to make herself.

  5. 23

    says

    Every morning I have a couple of cups of coffee with a QUITE A LOT OF CREAM. Great recipe, just my kind of yum! (Sharon)

    Another big Thank You for sharing at the BeBetsy BRAG ABOUT IT BeBetsy BRAG ABOUT IT.

    Sharon and Denise ♥
    Fashion | Food | Beauty | Antiques | DIY | and much more

  6. 28

    says

    I use a ton of coffee creamer too! This is a great way to save money. This post would fit in perfectly with Frugal Crafty Home Blog Hop’s theme & our readers would love to see this. I’d love it if you linked this up to our hop. Just click on “Carrie This Home” next to my picture and that will take you right to the hop.
    Thank you and have a great day!

  7. 31

    Anonymous says

    I don’t use any kind od coffee creamer, but my husband drinks a litle bit of coffee with his creamer…he prefers hazlenut….but the reason I am commenting is, I have to disagree with you on the vanilla, NOTHING can compare to pure Vanillas extract…the imitation (cheap) does not even come close to real vanilla….I make my own…a fifth of good grade vodka with 8 split vanilla beans and allow to sit for 6 weeks….It is the best vanilla you will ever taste…and anything that calls for vanilla, it has to be good or the end product is well, less than a quality product..now I am going to make my hubby some hazel nut coffee creamer…he goes thru this stuf like crazy!!!!

  8. 35

    Anonymous says

    Okay, that looks simple enough! But I want Pumpkin Spice creamer; my girls use a LOT!! I’m assuming I would still use some vanilla, but what then? Pumpkin pie spice mix?
    Thanks for your help and the recipe!

    • 36

      says

      I haven’t tried adding a pumpkin element to this. But I did do some research for you and found that Torani has a pumpkin spice syrup. If you used pumpkin pie spice (the powder), I have a feeling that the powder might float to the top or your cup once you add your coffee. So I think it might be safer to just swap out the caramel syrup for the pumpkin spice syrup.

      If you do try it, please let me know how it turns out – I’d love to try some myself!

    • 43

      Anonymous says

      I don’t think you save a lot, but if you run out of store bought or just want something without corn syrup and chemicals, this recipe is AWESOME!!

  9. 44

    Anonymous says

    Sounds great, but worried the sweetened condensed milk will make it too sweet? Going to have to play with this and see what I can do to make it less sweet.

    • 47

      says

      Due to the cost of living in my area, I’m not saving an incredible amount of money since milk is over $4 per gallon here. But if you live in a lower cost of living area, I do think there would be considerable savings.

  10. 48

    says

    Jazmin,
    thank you so much for the link love!! I’ve been dying to make some different flavors, but just haven’t gotten around to it yet. Caramel is one of my favorites and definitely on my to-do list!
    Thanks again and I wish you an amazing 2014!

  11. 50

    says

    This looks so yummy! I usually just put skim milk in my coffee, but I may have to try this. I bet it would be great in an iced coffee as well. Thanks for linking up to the Thursday STYLE link party! Hope to see you at the party again this week!

    • 53

      says

      Due to the cost of living in my area, I’m not saving an incredible amount of money since milk is over $4 per gallon here. But if you live in a lower cost of living area, I do think there would be considerable savings.

    • 55

      says

      I haven’t yet (I am so forgetful!) but I will price it out next time I make this. My gut instinct tells me I’m not saving an incredible amount of money since milk is over $4 per gallon in my area. But if you live in a lower cost of living area, I do think there would be considerable savings.

  12. 56

    Anonymous says

    If you like the cinnamon/vanilla, instead of making the special creamer you can add a dash of cinnamon and 1/2 t. of vanilla to the top of your ground and brew. Yummm

Trackbacks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>